What is Situational Leadership? Importance, Styles, and Benefits

In the world of leadership, rigidity is the enemy of progress. Situational Leadership turns flexibility into a fine art, letting leaders tailor their approach to match each scenario perfectly. Some days you lead from the front, others you guide from the sidelines. In this blog, we’ll unpack what is Situational Leadership, how it works, its benefits, and when to use it to get the best out of your team. Let's explore!

Table of Contents

1. What is Situational Leadership?

2. Who Created Situational Leadership?

3. Why is Situational Leadership Important?

4. Key Responsibilities of Situational Leaders

5. Situational Leadership Model Styles

6. Benefits and Limitations of Situational Leadership

7. Best Practices for Effective Situational Leadership

8. Conclusion
    

What is Situational Leadership?

Situational Leadership is a flexible, adaptive leadership model that suggests there is no single best way to lead. Instead, effective leaders adjust their style based on the competence, confidence, and commitment of the individuals or teams they are managing. This model focuses on aligning leadership behaviour with the team’s development level for a given task.

This not only improves task performance but also fosters trust, engagement, and long-term growth. The model is especially valuable in dynamic environments where team composition, goals, or challenges frequently change, requiring leaders to stay responsive and adaptable in their approach.

Key Requirement:

1. A culture of Psychological Safety

2. Accountability at all Levels

Who Created Situational Leadership?

Situational Leadership was originally developed in the late 1960s by Dr. Paul Hersey, a management expert, and Ken Blanchard, a leadership consultant and author. Together, they introduced the model in their book "Management of Organisational Behavior."

Hersey and Blanchard’s collaboration combined behavioural science with practical leadership strategies to create a model that emphasises adaptability and team development. Although they later developed separate versions, Hersey continued with the Situational Leadership® Model, while Blanchard introduced the SLII® Model. 

Why is Situational Leadership Important?

Situational Leadership provides the flexibility to lead effectively in a wide range of scenarios, helping individuals and teams thrive regardless of complexity or change. Here are some of the reasons: 

1. Supporting Skill Development

Situational Leadership enables leaders to tailor their approach based on an employee’s current skill level and confidence. A team member new to a task may need clear guidance, while someone more experienced may benefit from support or full autonomy. 

2. Integrating AI in the Workplace

As AI tools reshape job roles and processes, employees face new learning curves. Situational Leadership allows managers to provide close guidance during early stages of AI adoption, gradually shifting to a more hands-off approach as competence grows. 

3. Handling Uncertainty

Uncertainty whether caused by market shifts, organisational changes, or global disruptions can leave teams feeling unsettled. Situational Leadership empowers leaders to offer the right balance of direction and support, depending on how ready the team is to handle ambiguity. 

4. Responding to Rapid Change

Change is constant and accelerating. Situational Leadership allows leaders to shift gears quickly, aligning their leadership style with the current needs of the team. This flexible approach keeps teams agile, engaged, and ready to act without delay.

Think you’ve got leadership potential? Let’s prove it with CMI Level 3 Award in Principles of Management and Leadership – Start now!

Key Responsibilities of Situational Leaders

Situational leaders take on a dynamic set of responsibilities to support team growth, adapt to changing needs, and drive performance through flexibility and awareness.

1. Assess Readiness: Evaluate team member’s skills, confidence, and motivation for each task.

2. Adapt Style: Shift between directing, coaching, supporting, and delegating as needed.

3. Guide Appropriately: Offer the right level of direction based on task complexity and experience.

4. Develop Skills: Support individual growth by adjusting leadership as competence increases.

5. Ensure Psychological Safety: Create a safe space for open communication and learning.

6. Monitor and Adjust: Continuously reassess and adapt leadership approach.

7. Encourage Accountability: Promote shared responsibility across the team.

8. Communicate Clearly: Tailor messages to team member’s needs and development levels.

Situational Leadership Model Styles

Each style is tailored to match an individual’s competence and commitment for a specific task, helping leaders provide the right balance of direction and support to drive performance and growth. Let's discuss for further details: 

1. Directing (Telling) Style

This style is used when team members have low competence but high commitment, often beginners or those new to a specific task. The leader provides clear instructions, close supervision, and defined roles. Decision-making is primarily with the leader, as the team member is not yet ready for autonomy.

Best for: New hires, trainees, or situations where accuracy and clarity are critical.

2. Coaching (Selling) Style

Applied when team members have some competence but may lack confidence or motivation. Leaders still provide direction but add more two-way communication and encouragement. They explain decisions and seek input to build buy-in and engagement. 

Best For: Developing team members who need support to grow skills and motivation.

3. Supporting (Participating) Style

Used when team members are competent but may lack confidence or need motivation. Here, the leader offers less direction and more emotional support, encouraging participation in decision-making. The focus shifts from task instruction to motivation and collaboration.

Best For: Capable individuals needing a confidence boost or stronger team ownership.

4. Delegating Style

Ideal when team members are highly competent, confident, and committed. The leader steps back, allowing the individual or team to take full responsibility for decisions and execution. The leader's role becomes minimal, offering trust and autonomy.

Best For: Experienced, self-directed individuals or high-performing teams.

Benefits and Limitations of Situational Leadership

Situational Leadership like any leadership model, it also comes with certain limitations. The table below highlights the key benefits and challenges of using Situational Leadership:

Benefits 

Situational Leadership offers a dynamic and responsive way to lead teams, helping leaders match their approach to the needs of individuals and specific situations.

1. Flexibility: Leaders can adapt their style based on the needs of individuals and situations, making it suitable for dynamic work environments.

2. Supports Team Development: By adjusting leadership behaviour, leaders help team members grow in competence and confidence over time.

3. Improved Communication: Tailored interactions based on each team member’s development level lead to clearer expectations and better alignment.

4. Encourages Autonomy: As individuals develop, leaders shift toward delegating, empowering team members and building trust.

5. Effective in Diverse Teams: Situational Leadership accommodates different working styles, personalities, and levels of experience within the same team.

6. Boosts Performance: Matching leadership to readiness leads to higher engagement, motivation, and productivity.

Grab your opportunities and lead the way with your CMI Level 3 Diploma in Principles of Management and Leadership – Sign up today!

Limitations

Despite its flexibility, Situational Leadership has certain challenges that may limit its effectiveness in some environments.

1. Requires Accurate Assessment: Leaders must accurately assess each team member’s competence and commitment, which can be subjective and time-consuming.

2. Can Be Inconsistent: Shifting styles frequently may confuse teams if not communicated effectively.

3. Heavily Dependent on Leader's Skill: Success depends on the leader’s ability to recognise development levels and apply the right style at the right time.

4. Less Effective Without Trust: If psychological safety or accountability is lacking, the approach may not yield results.

5. Not Ideal for All Situations: In highly regulated or urgent environments, adaptability may be limited and a consistent approach may be preferred.

Best Practices for Effective Situational Leadership

To make this leadership style truly effective, leaders must consciously balance direction and support, stay flexible in their approach, and maintain open lines of communication. The following best practices can help leaders excel in applying Situational Leadership in real-world settings.

1. Recognise the Balance Between Task and Relationship Behaviours

Strong situational leaders help in building trust and maintaining healthy working relationships. Too much focus on tasks can lead to burnout or disengagement, while overemphasis on relationships might slow progress. 

By finding the right equilibrium, leaders can ensure productivity without sacrificing team morale, fostering a healthy and high-performing work environment.

2. Apply Varied Leadership Styles Based on the Situation

The strength of Situational Leadership lies in its flexibility. Leaders must be able to switch between directing, coaching, supporting, and delegating depending on team capability, confidence, and the urgency of the task. 

For example, a new team member might benefit from a more directive style at first, while a seasoned professional might thrive under a delegative approach. Being able to adapt on the fly ensures that leadership remains relevant and effective.

3. Align your Leadership Approach with the Task at Hand

Situational leaders assess the scope, complexity, and importance of a task before deciding how involved they should be. 

A high-stakes project with tight deadlines might need clear step-by-step guidance, while a routine task can be handed over with minimal oversight. This alignment prevents wasted effort and improves overall efficiency.

4. Prioritise Ongoing Leadership Training

The workplace is constantly evolving, and so should leadership skills. Continuous professional development. Leadership trainings, coaching, seminars, and industry networking equips leaders with fresh strategies and tools. 

This commitment to learning not only sharpens decision-making and adaptability but also sets a positive example for team members. It encourages them to embrace growth and skill development as part of their own career journey.

5. Foster Open, Two-way Communication

Adaptability in leadership hinges on clear, open, and honest dialogue. Leaders who actively listen, seek feedback, and address concerns promptly create an atmosphere of trust and psychological safety. 

Encouraging employees to share their perspectives ensures leaders have the insights needed to adjust their style effectively. Two-way communication also boosts transparency, reduces misunderstandings, and strengthens team cohesion.

Conclusion

Situational Leadership is about adapting your approach to fit the needs of your team and the task at hand. By balancing guidance and support, leaders can motivate their teams, improve performance, and handle challenges effectively. It’s a flexible style that works across industries, making leadership more responsive and results driven.

Shape your leadership future - Secure your place with the CMI Level 3 Training today!